Best of City Search
- Best of City2009
- Best of Dessert2008
- Best of Dessert2007
- Best of Dessert2006
AOL's City Best
- 5-Star Rating2008
- 5-Star Rating2007
- 5-Star Rating2006
Cincinnati Magazine Best of The City
- Best Torte: Opera Cream2004
- Hall of Fame Best Bakery & Best Scones2004
- Best Layer Cake2003
- Best Afternoon Escape2002
- Best Bakery, Reader's Choice Best Local Flavor2001
- Hall of Fame2001
- Hall of Fame2000
- Hall of Fame & Best Tea Time1999
Citybeat Best of Cincinnati
- Best Baby2009
- Best Wedding Cake2009
- Best Desserts2009
- Best Bakery2003
- Best Desserts2002
- Best Desserts2001
- Best Yule Log2000
- Best Sweets1999
Everybody's News Best of Cincinnati
- Best Desserts1996
Retail Baker's Association National Competition
- Gold Medal for Richard Prince, Head Decorator2004
- Silver Medal2001
- Gold Medal2001
- Silver Medal2000
Wherethelocalseat.com
- One of Top 100 Restaurants in Cincinnati2008
Yelp.com
- Favorite Cincinnati Bakery2009
- Four Stars2008
The Knot
- Knot Best of Wedding2009
- Knot Best of Wedding2008
- Best of Wedding2007
Zagat Survey
- Extraordinary2009
- Extraordinary2008
- Extraordinary2006
- Extraordinary2005
- Extraordinary (1 of only 2 in the city)2004
- Excellent & Best Tea Room2000
- Excellent1999
- Excellent1997
Cincinnati USA Regional Chamber
- Best Woman Owned Business in Cincinnati Runner Up2008